Whispers of an imminent comeback for Bayley are growing louder, and the most compelling theory making the rounds involves “The Role Model” taking on a new leadership position. Speculation is running high that Bayley could return to WWE television as the head of the heel faction Fatal Influence.
The group, currently making waves in NXT and TNA, consists of Fallon Henley, Jazmyn Nyx, and reigning NXT Women’s Champion Jacy Jayne. The basis for this theory stems from Bayley’s past success leading Damage CTRL and a notable tweet where she called Jayne “very smart.” A move like this would not only bring Fatal Influence to the main roster but would also cement a significant heel turn for the seven-time champion.
This potential dark direction, however, runs directly counter to the emotional conflict that defined her most recent television appearances.
I THINK YOU’RE VERY SMART JACY
— Bayley (@itsBayleyWWE) September 10, 2025
The Storyline Behind Bayley’s Hiatus
Before her current hiatus, Bayley was portrayed as being in an “internal war” with herself. A vignette on the September 8th edition of RAW showed her grappling with her aggressive “Role Model” persona and her classic “Hugger” gimmick.
The segment concluded with a tearful Bayley choosing to make things right with Lyra Valkyria, whom she had hurt during their recent tag team run. This unresolved babyface turmoil makes the speculation about her leading a new villainous group all the more intriguing.