A new romantic storyline may be developing within The Judgment Day faction after Women’s Tag Team Champion Liv Morgan shared a revealing conversation with Carlito on her Instagram.

Morgan uploaded a video featuring Carlito where she directly asked him about his romantic interests within WWE.

The conversation took an interesting turn when Carlito admitted his attraction to Raquel Rodriguez, Morgan’s current tag team partner.

Between you and me, I think Raquel’s kind of hot.

Carlito also confirmed that he has a crush on Rodriguez during their interaction.

Morgan responded to his confession by offering to help facilitate a potential relationship between the two Judgment Day members.

The seeds for this potential storyline appear to have been planted for some time, as Carlito has reportedly been flirtatious with Rodriguez during their interactions.

Despite Carlito’s interest, Rodriguez has not shown reciprocal romantic interest in the former United States Champion.

This potential storyline comes at a time of significant change within The Judgment Day faction.

Rumors suggest Finn Balor may soon depart the group, while JD McDonagh is currently inactive due to injury.

If these changes materialize, Carlito would be left as the primary male figure in the faction, potentially creating a new dynamic for the group.

A romantic angle involving Rodriguez and Carlito could provide fresh storytelling possibilities for The Judgment Day and keep the faction relevant during this transition period.

Ver essa foto no Instagram

Uma publicação compartilhada por Liv Morgan (@yaonlylivvonce)

Carlito might be written off WWE programming following last week’s brutal attack from Intercontinental Champion Bron Breakker on Monday Night RAW. The Judgment Day member was left twitching in pain after Breakker caught him at ringside and delivered a devastating Spear.

Tonight on RAW, General Manager Adam Pearce could potentially announce that Carlito has suffered a storyline injury as a result of Breakker’s attack. This announcement would establish that the Judgment Day member is medically unfit to compete, leading to his temporary absence from the red brand.

This potential angle would likely serve to advance upcoming storylines. While Carlito may be temporarily removed from television, his absence could set the stage for Finn Balor to step into a feud with Breakker for the Intercontinental Championship.

The timing of this potential development aligns with WrestleMania season, potentially building toward a championship showdown at WrestleMania 41. Some fans have noted possible hints at the return of Balor’s “Demon” persona, which could be incorporated into this storyline as it progresses.

Balor has not utilized his Demon character on the main roster for some time, but recent subtle references have sparked speculation about its potential resurrection specifically for a high-profile match against Breakker.

This potential storyline development remains speculative at this point, with confirmation expected during tonight’s broadcast from Madison Square Garden.

Carlito finna be coughing up blood backstage like an anime character after that spear from Bron Breakker 😭 #WWERAW pic.twitter.com/xuMoDz2Qmo— Public Enemies Podcast (@PublicEnemiesHQ) March 4, 2025

The Judgment Day members referred to Carlito with a new nickname during backstage segments on WWE RAW. Both Liv Morgan and Finn Balor addressed the former United States Champion as “Carly” in separate interactions throughout the show.

Morgan used the nickname while discussing with Dominik Mysterio her reaction to his attempted reconciliation with Rhea Ripley last week. After receiving flowers from Dominik, she tossed them to Carlito, addressing him as “Carly.” Later in the evening, Finn Balor also used the same moniker when speaking with Carlito before his Street Fight against Damian Priest.

dom has a lotta work to do… 🫣 pic.twitter.com/qW2nIw3dDB— WWE (@WWE) January 14, 2025

Carlito’s Role in The Judgment Day

Initially joining The Judgment Day to avoid confrontations with Rey Mysterio and the LWO on RAW, Carlito has maintained his position within the faction for nearly a year. His tenure with the group has now exceeded that of both Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley, who departed following the events at SummerSlam in August.