Finn Balor is experiencing a difficult period in his wrestling career, having recently failed to qualify for the Men’s Elimination Chamber match after suffering another defeat against Seth Rollins this week on RAW. This unfortunate streak of losses might provide Dominik Mysterio and Liv Morgan the opportunity they need to replace The Prince in The Judgment Day with rumored WWE returnee and two-time champion Malakai Black.
For several weeks, Dominik has been proposing the introduction of a new member to reinvigorate The Judgment Day’s momentum. While Balor has consistently opposed this suggestion, his recent defeat against Rollins could expose the vulnerability that Mysterio and Morgan have been waiting to exploit, potentially leading to the faction turning against their established member.
The power couple could confront Finn Balor in the ring during next week’s RAW, challenging his value to The Judgment Day. They might argue that his inability to secure personal success undermines his capacity to elevate the faction as a whole. This confrontation could culminate in a devastating ambush, with Balor receiving an unexpected kick from Malakai Black, signaling the former NXT and AEW World Trios Champion’s return to WWE programming.
Such a dramatic return would likely send shockwaves through the WWE Universe, establishing Black’s position within The Judgment Day as the faction acknowledges his arrival. The 39-year-old performer has been heavily rumored to make his return to the Stamford-based promotion following his recent departure from AEW, making this scenario a compelling possibility.
It’s important to note that this entire scenario remains speculative at this point. Whether the rumors surrounding Malakai Black’s return materialize into reality remains to be seen as WWE continues to develop its ongoing storylines.
New member to replace Finn Balor in Judgment Day should be Aleister Black
— Chris (@enforcerchris_) February 18, 2025
Finn Balor vs Aleister Black at WrestleMania 🔥#WWERaw pic.twitter.com/OOZ5i1aJXD